Election Day, Nov 3 3 daysSenate D 85%House D 97%Governors D 84%Forecast updated Oct 31

How healthy is each campaign, and how does each side win? A health score for both campaigns in every Senate, governor and contested House race, and the path to victory for each side.

Senate · Minnesota · open seat

Minnesota Senate

Peggy Flanagan vs Michele Tafoya

ForecastD +12.0
Democrat98%
Republican2%
RatingSafe D
Full forecast
Brief me as

Neutral view. Pick a side and the War Room briefs you as that campaign's operative.

Vital signs

Campaign health, 0 to 100, from public money, outside spending, ballots and activity
DemocratPeggy FlanaganStable
630100
  • Money weight 2552

    Raised $10.3M against $9.6M for Michele Tafoya.

  • Cash weight 2044

    $1.1M in the bank against $1.4M for Michele Tafoya. As of 07/22/2026.

  • Air cover weight 1570

    Outside groups spent $2.7M helping Peggy Flanagan and $1.1M helping Michele Tafoya.

  • National tide weight 1576

    Gallup party identification moved from Republicans 48 Democrats 45 in the third quarter of 2024 to Democrats 50 Republicans 39 in the third quarter of 2026, 14 points toward the Democrats. This race moves 0.82 points for every point the nation moves, so it feels about 11.5 points of that tide, a tailwind for Peggy Flanagan.

  • Activity weight 10100

    5 campaign stops by the candidate or surrogates in 30 days. 3 mentions on shows and podcasts in two weeks. $447K in Google political ads this cycle. 1 story on the On Point news desk in two weeks.

RepublicanMichele TafoyaStrained
460100
  • Money weight 2548

    Raised $9.6M against $10.3M for Peggy Flanagan.

  • Cash weight 2056

    $1.4M in the bank against $1.1M for Peggy Flanagan. As of 07/22/2026.

  • Air cover weight 1530

    Outside groups spent $1.1M helping Michele Tafoya and $2.7M helping Peggy Flanagan.

  • National tide weight 1524

    Gallup party identification moved from Republicans 48 Democrats 45 in the third quarter of 2024 to Democrats 50 Republicans 39 in the third quarter of 2026, 14 points toward the Democrats. This race moves 0.82 points for every point the nation moves, so it feels about 11.5 points of that tide, a headwind for Michele Tafoya.

  • Activity weight 1075

    3 campaign stops by the candidate or surrogates in 30 days. 5 mentions on shows and podcasts in two weeks. $38K in Google political ads this cycle.

How each side wins

From the forecast, the polls, the county map, voter groups, money and ballots
If you work for Peggy Flanagan
  1. Protect the lead

    Peggy Flanagan leads by 12.0 in the forecast and wins 98% of simulations. The cushion is about 336,808 votes; a one point swing is about 13,999 voters changing sides.

  2. The range

    In 8 of 10 simulations the result lands between D +5.3 and D +18.8. Only an unusual polling error changes the winner.

  3. The polls

    The polls page average is D +8.8. Your best recent poll is New York Times/Siena at D +13.3; your worst is InsiderAdvantage at D +1.1. 13 polls in the last 30 days.

  4. Turn out the base

    The biggest vote banks for Democrats: Hennepin, a projected net 304,219 votes; Ramsey, a projected net 132,818 votes; Dakota, a projected net 33,048 votes. Every point of extra turnout here is worth more than persuasion anywhere else.

  5. Win the battlegrounds

    The large counties within 12 points: Anoka, D +3.4, 6.3% of the vote; Washington, D +9.5, 5.1% of the vote; Scott, R +6.7, 2.7% of the vote; Carver, R +9.7, 2.1% of the vote.

  6. Where you run behind the 2024 map

    Against the 2024 presidential vote, Peggy Flanagan runs furthest behind in Carver, Washington, Wright. That is where the forecast sees voters who backed your side two years ago and have not come back yet.

  7. The coalition levers

    Groups big enough to move the race: White voters, 87% of voters, 52 to 45, where a 5 point gain is worth 4.36 points; Voters who cast ballots in 2022 and 2024, 75% of voters, 55 to 43, where a 5 point gain is worth 3.75 points; Voters who find daily costs hard to afford, 59% of voters, 59 to 38, where a 5 point gain is worth 2.94 points.

  8. Where you lose ground

    The forecast's worst groups for Peggy Flanagan: Immigration voters 21 to 77, Small counties 39 to 58, Midsize counties 48 to 49. Cutting the loss here is often cheaper than winning new groups.

  9. The money

    $1.1M cash against $1.4M. Roughly even money; the air war will be decided by outside groups and earned media.

  10. What the ballots so far say

    The early vote has moved this forecast 0.2 points away from Peggy Flanagan. Election Day has to make it up: the remaining vote must break harder your way than the forecast expects.

  11. Michele Tafoya's strongest asset

    Activity: 3 campaign stops by the candidate or surrogates in 30 days.

If you work for Michele Tafoya
  1. Close the gap

    Michele Tafoya trails by 12.0 and wins 2% of simulations. Closing it takes about 168,404 voters switching sides, or 336,808 more net votes from new turnout.

  2. The range

    In 8 of 10 simulations the result lands between D +18.8 and D +5.3. Only an unusual polling error changes the winner.

  3. The polls

    The polls page average is D +8.8. Your best recent poll is InsiderAdvantage at D +1.1; your worst is New York Times/Siena at D +13.3. 13 polls in the last 30 days.

  4. Turn out the base

    The biggest vote banks for Republicans: Wright, a projected net 20,248 votes; Sherburne, a projected net 13,803 votes; Stearns, a projected net 12,887 votes. Every point of extra turnout here is worth more than persuasion anywhere else.

  5. Win the battlegrounds

    The large counties within 12 points: Anoka, D +3.4, 6.3% of the vote; Washington, D +9.5, 5.1% of the vote; Scott, R +6.7, 2.7% of the vote; Carver, R +9.7, 2.1% of the vote.

  6. Where you run behind the 2024 map

    Against the 2024 presidential vote, Michele Tafoya runs furthest behind in St. Louis, Olmsted, Blue Earth. That is where the forecast sees voters who backed your side two years ago and have not come back yet.

  7. The coalition levers

    Groups big enough to move the race: White voters, 87% of voters, 45 to 52, where a 5 point gain is worth 4.36 points; Voters who cast ballots in 2022 and 2024, 75% of voters, 43 to 55, where a 5 point gain is worth 3.75 points; Voters who find daily costs hard to afford, 59% of voters, 38 to 59, where a 5 point gain is worth 2.94 points.

  8. Where you lose ground

    The forecast's worst groups for Michele Tafoya: Black voters 17 to 80, Corruption voters 21 to 76, Asian and other voters 26 to 71. Cutting the loss here is often cheaper than winning new groups.

  9. The money

    $1.4M cash against $1.1M. Roughly even money; the air war will be decided by outside groups and earned media.

  10. What the ballots so far say

    The early vote has moved this forecast 0.2 points toward Michele Tafoya. Bank it: chase the remaining mail ballots and low propensity voters who have not voted.

  11. Peggy Flanagan's strongest asset

    Activity: 5 campaign stops by the candidate or surrogates in 30 days.

The map for Flanagan

County projections from the forecast
Vote banksWhere the biggest net margins come from
CountyForecastVote shareNet D
HennepinD +47.023.1%+304,219
RamseyD +52.89%+132,818
DakotaD +14.88%+33,048
St. LouisD +30.53.7%+31,501
BattlegroundsLarge counties within 12 points
CountyForecastVote shareNet D
AnokaD +3.46.3%+5,982
WashingtonD +9.55.1%+13,668
ScottR +6.72.7%-5,080
CarverR +9.72.1%-5,610
Behind the 2024 mapRunning furthest behind the last presidential vote
CountyForecastVote shareNet D
CarverR +9.72.1%-5,610
WashingtonD +9.55.1%+13,668
WrightR +28.22.6%-20,248

The coalition

Flanagan against Tafoya among the groups that can move it, from the forecast's voter group estimates
Swing groups
  • White voters87% of voters · a 5 point gain is worth 4.4
    5245
  • Voters who cast ballots in 2022 and 202475% of voters · a 5 point gain is worth 3.8
    5543
  • Voters who find daily costs hard to afford59% of voters · a 5 point gain is worth 2.9
    5939
  • Voters without a degree56% of voters · a 5 point gain is worth 2.8
    5245
Weakest groups
  • Immigration voters9% of voters · a 5 point gain is worth 0.4
    2177
  • Small counties27% of voters · a 5 point gain is worth 1.3
    3958
  • Midsize counties27% of voters · a 5 point gain is worth 1.3
    4949
FlanaganTafoya

Scouting report

From the Watchdog people files, each line with its source
Peggy Flanagan

No researched file yet; this candidate is queued for the next people file batch.

Michele Tafoya

No researched file yet; this candidate is queued for the next people file batch.

The forecast

Margin over recent runs
R +2.0D +12.821 runs agonow
Now
D +12.0
8 in 10 land between
D +18.8 and D +5.3
Polling average
D +8.8
Partisan lean
D +5.8
Early vote effect
R +0.2

Recent polls

Last 45 days
PollsterDays agoSampleResult
Trafalgar Group (R)01,079 LVD +4.7
Rasmussen Reports (R)01,182 LVD +4.4
New York Times/Siena0752 LVD +13.3
Victory Insights for the Tafoya campaign (R)01,194 LVD +5.3
KSTP/SurveyUSA0714 LVD +6.4
KSTP/SurveyUSA3650 LVD +2.4
Mason-Dixon for the Star Tribune8800 LVD +4.8
Morning Consult81,000 RVD +3.5
Rasmussen Reports (R)8856 LVD +4.4
GQR (D)11800 LVD +7.6
Big Data Poll15622 LVD +1.7
InsiderAdvantage161,200 LVD +1.1

Money and the air war

Reports as of 07/22/2026
FlanaganTafoya
Raised$10.3M$9.6M
Spent$5.5M$4.0M
Cash on hand$1.1M$1.4M
Outside money for$2.7M$1.1M
Google ads$447K$38K
Biggest outside spenders
  • North Star Dawn PAC for Angie Craig$14.2M
  • AB PAC for Peggy Flanagan$1.4M
  • Minnesota Forward against Peggy Flanagan$1.1M
  • Working America for Peggy Flanagan$162K
Ad buys
  • Outside groups combined, airings 9/28 to 10/11 Source$160K
Follow the money

The early vote

Minnesota, through 2026-10-30
Ballots cast
728,961
Party data
Modeled, the state does not report party
Ballot margin
D +29.6
Forecast expected
D +30.7
Against expectation
1.0 points better for Republicans

Party registration of who has voted, not how they voted.

Open the early vote tracker

Media watch

Who is putting this race in front of an audience
  • 2026-10-26
    Guy Benson host, leans R

    Interviewed Republican Michele Tafoya on The Guy Benson Show, asking if fraud and Somali gang violence resonate in a blue state; she said Peggy Flanagan is not an experiment worth retrying. Source

  • 2026-10-22
    Cook Political Report analyst

    Shifted the Minnesota Senate race between Peggy Flanagan and Michele Tafoya from Likely Democrat to Lean Democrat. Source

  • 2026-10-21
    Steve Kornacki analyst

    On Today warned a tide seems to be working against Democrats in Minnesota's Flanagan vs Tafoya race. Source

  • 2026-10-21
    Sandra Smith host

    Pressed Michele Tafoya on whether a Trump campaign visit would help or hurt her. Source

  • 2026-10-20
    Karl Rove commentator, leans R

    Said he believes in Republican Michele Tafoya but would not predict a win. Source

  • 2026-10-16
    Rich Baris analyst, leans R

    Said Democrat Peggy Flanagan's lead had grown to four points. Source

  • 2026-08-13
    Larry Kudlow host, leans R

    Claimed Peggy Flanagan is pushing a Native American identity as cover for socialism, comparing her to Elizabeth Warren. Source

Media watch

On the trail

Rallies and events, newest first
  • 2026-11-01
    Pete Buttigieg announced in

    Announced Sunday Minnesota stop; city not given, date inferred from weekday. Source

  • 2026-10-16
    Peggy Flanagan debate in St. Paul

    Only scheduled debate with Michele Tafoya, hosted by Minnesota Public Radio. Source

  • 2026-10-16
    Peggy Flanagan tour stop in Moorhead

    Got Your Back tour stop focused on affordability and farm policy. Source

  • 2026-10-16
    Michele Tafoya debate in St. Paul

    Only scheduled debate with Peggy Flanagan, hosted by Minnesota Public Radio. Source

  • 2026-10-15
    Peggy Flanagan event in Apple Valley

    Meet and greet with families alongside state Sen. Erin Maye Quade, per a campaign advisory. Source

  • 2026-10-13
    Michele Tafoya event in St. Paul

    News conference at the Capitol to unveil a five point public safety plan with leaders of the Minnesota Police and Peace Officers Association. Source

  • 2026-10-10
    Peggy Flanagan event in Eden Prairie

    Press conference on reproductive rights with Rep. Kelly Morrison and Planned Parenthood leaders Alexis McGill Johnson and Ruth Richardson. Source

  • 2026-10-05
    Michele Tafoya event in Le Sueur

    Farm roundtable and remarks with Senate Majority Leader John Thune, farmers and farm group leaders. Source

  • 2026-10-04
    Peggy Flanagan event in Appleton

    Stop outside a private prison being converted to a federal detention center, part of her Got Your Back tour of 30 stops in 30 days. Source

From the news desk

Races that move with this one

When the polls miss here, they tend to miss there too